Contest comments:
friiskiwi: must it be a tree leaf?
(2 years and 344 days ago)
nofue: has it to be on the tree still?
(2 years and 343 days ago)
bluefly: don't think it needs to be on a tree.
(2 years and 343 days ago)
kyricom: This contest seems to favor those in tropical climates. They have much cooler leaves.
(2 years and 343 days ago)
nofue: I think it depends how you shoot a leaf (or anything for that matter). Photography is about getting a great look on even the dullest subject...
(2 years and 343 days ago)
kyricom: You're absolutely correct nofue, but they still have cooler leaves. (and that billboard contest is sure exciting)
(2 years and 343 days ago)
Epazia: i have seen some really amazing dead leaves!
(2 years and 343 days ago)
Epazia: I don't live in the tropics. Lol not even close.
(2 years and 343 days ago)
stelios: nice pick
(2 years and 342 days ago)
Epazia: have we just decided the guideline for this contest do not apply? i am really confused?
(2 years and 342 days ago)
jeanine2: there are a lot of off topic images.. apparantly the guidelines are not applying on this one..
(2 years and 342 days ago)
kyricom: It should matter. Either red flag them or vote low
(2 years and 342 days ago)
bluefly: red flag them so the mods can look at them. theres currently only two doing all the contests so be patient. If you know it came from somewhere on the web give us the web site. thanks
(2 years and 342 days ago)
bluefly: jeanine2 trees only? is that what you suggested? Or any single leaf.
(2 years and 342 days ago)
Epazia: kind of unfair to change the rules now?
(2 years and 342 days ago)
jeanine2: it was meant for trees.. the guidelines even say "she us the pretty leaves on your trees" it was meant to challenge the creativity and make a dull object come to life.
(2 years and 342 days ago)
TRussotto: If the guidelines are not applied to all entries it wouldn't be fair to those who followed them. Just my honest opinion. You have to read the guidelines.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
friiskiwi: So is the general idea that the leaves must not only be from a tree, but also still attached to a tree.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
bluefly: sometimes even the mods need a clearification, so they know how to handle the flagged items.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
friiskiwi: I have removed my non attached leaves, but I do agree with your ruling.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
friiskiwi: I ment to add, and your reason.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
snappler: Thanks for the explanation. Try try again.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
frankiebenka: how then do you define "tree"
(2 years and 341 days ago)
Epazia: Hang in there Mod. Good job =D
(2 years and 341 days ago)
TRussotto: My voting is all messed up. The guidlelines should have been made clearer.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
wow-goldfish: you just hav to put a single tree leaf I put plant leaves and they got taken off!
(2 years and 341 days ago)
frankiebenka: you should not be voting based on theme anyway, that is the mods job.
(2 years and 341 days ago)
adeincyprus: hang on a minute!!!!............there are still shots here, which are not tree leaves!!. Now either we are allowed non tree leaves or we are not, which is it. You can't remove some shots and not others, and are you guys experts on trees, no offense meant!, do you know which are trees and which are plants, because there are cerainly non tree leaves still here. I am not going to enter a shot if it is going to be removed, because I have my doubts about the choices being made about which should be removed and which shouldn't....
(2 years and 340 days ago)
adeincyprus: As a suggestion for the mods and admin, perhaps before contests are put up, there should be some clarification about what the suggested contest actually is and what it should contain. Too often, we have come to a contest, only to have to ask questions about what we are allowed, and what we are not.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
kyricom: I agree with Ade that it might be good to have some quick communication with the ones suggesting things just so the moderators are clear - so they can help us be clear. Often, wording is very vague or confusing. Many times this may be the result of English not being their primary language. That's a cool part of this site. But those themes could be fixed up before posting, helping everyone. I'd be happy to help with the wording of them if you'd like.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
bluefly: remember that the mods are not on line 24/7. I look up the leaf that has been entered, I can usually tell a leaf from a tree.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
smokebigbird: I just had a pic removed for not being on a tree, sorry to tell u but those leaves are still on the tree, what mor do u want, i tryed to focuse on just the leaves, so do u want more of the tree and not the leaves?????, NOT HAPPY AT ALL
(2 years and 340 days ago)
smokebigbird: I just had a pic removed for not being on a tree, sorry to tell u but those leaves are still on the tree, what mor do u want, i tryed to focuse on just the leaves, so do u want more of the tree and not the leaves?????, NOT HAPPY AT ALL
(2 years and 340 days ago)
bluefly: Sorry, but its hard to satisfy everyone. There are other leaves that were removed because more than one is in focus and there were multiple red flags on images.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
bluefly: Palm trees have fronds which look kind of like multiple leaves on one stem. but it's one leaf. I hope this helps.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
wow-goldfish: Its unfair my ivy leaves got taken of but there are othere ppl with plant leaves!
(2 years and 340 days ago)
mv96: oh boy..I feel bad for many. I've been through this before. BUT, I think if the guidelines are "edited" in advance, with easier descriptions, everyone should be able to understand the pre-text of "what" is permissable. ie: "tree leaf" no others. Also, maybe a team member can monitor what pics comply and the ones that don't, kindly notify author, and let them resubmit again, as you do. I'd be happy to be involved in any English grammer, since I am a writer..

just trying to help here.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
TRussotto: frankiebenka: Don't tell me how to vote. I take in consideration if an image is on theme or not when I vote. I don't tell you how to vote!
(2 years and 340 days ago)
nofue: Jeez, that's quite some thread. Folks, there are forums for stuff like this... As of voting: there is no point considering voting on a picture which is off topic. If it is off topic -- the mods decide -- it will be dq'ed anyway, just raise the red flag. But vote on the picture as if it were on topic. I.e. judge focus, color, tonality, composition, framing, visual impact first. That's at least 60% of the picture. The final 40% are artistic take on the subject, creativity, wow factor, whatever. But don't vote low just because you don't get the author's way to deal with the subject -- sometimes it's easy to be mislead by pictures (and words, as seen in this thread

)
(2 years and 340 days ago)
TRussotto: I'll vote the way I always have. I've never had a problem and I've been here since the first day this site opened.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
TRussotto: I'll vote the way I always have. I've never had a problem and I've been here since the first day this site opened.
(2 years and 340 days ago)
serious: Please be patient was away for a bit and have even requested one of my own entries removed because it did not follow the guidelines...please do not be disappointed if you see entries removed
(2 years and 340 days ago)
colourblindmonkey: ok im confused 2 of my shots were taken down because the leaves were not on a tree, I have no problems if the leaves have to be on a tree but didnt the Moderator say "Since the photo at the top has a tree leaf on the ground, leaves on and off the tree will be allowed. Any non tree leaf will be removed. Sorry for the miscommunications." If this has changed please as im just confused what the final rules are
(2 years and 339 days ago)
Epazia: yup my single leaf on a tree just got removed too i give up on this one its just become silly
(2 years and 339 days ago)
jackie78: Yep im confused too as to what going on here, The moderators on this one need to make one clear judgement as to what the rule are going to be(not leaving it um yeah maybee, actuall no you cant), reading all the comments no wonder everyone is conffused....
(2 years and 339 days ago)
bluefly: The last set of photo's that were removed was a collected decison by all the mods. It is aknowleged that the photo is not correct but the desicion was made that they be removed. Even mods have had their photo's removed.
(2 years and 339 days ago)
slates: My photo was just removed and the explanation is crap. I personaly think this particular photo comp is a farse. The sample picture shows the leaf of a tree on the ground, yet now suddenly they have to be still on the trees. What is that all about ?
(2 years and 339 days ago)
serious: Trees come bearing leaves. Show us the pretty leaves on your trees. Can be of any time of year but must be focused on one single leaf. The photo above the description of the contest is confusing and off topic in the future we all need to read the contest guidelines and disregard the photos above the contests
(2 years and 339 days ago)
mv96: Okay...only "ONE" 1 leaf... repeat after me, "ONLY ONE LEAF" okey-dokey
(2 years and 338 days ago)
jerostone: Question: if photos of the suggested topics are confusing, (which they are,) then why you post them?
(2 years and 337 days ago)
slates: I agree jerostone, on the old site when these phots where not there, I dont think we had this problem.
(2 years and 337 days ago)
slates:

this is funny really, even after all this debate, there are still photos coming up that have leaves not on the trees
(2 years and 337 days ago)
bluefly: it's not the mods who are choosing the photo's. This is still a work in progress for the site to have the photos.
(2 years and 337 days ago)
jerostone: I think it's easy; simply don't post photos of the topics suggested, like you used to.
(2 years and 337 days ago)